MAGAZINE > ASK DAVE > RUMORS > EXPERTS > RANKINGS > TFP RADIO SHOW > CONTACT US

 

 Home |
 >> Scores / Schedule
 >> Injuries
 NHL RUMORS
 >> Rumors
 TFP RADIO SHOW
 >> Radio Home
 >> Broadcast Schedule
 TFP MAGAZINE
 >> Magazine Home
 >> Subscribe Now!
 FEATURES
 >> Ask Dave
 >> Rankings
 >> Experts
 >> Team Reports
 SPECIAL EVENTS
 >> 2006 World Juniors
 >> 2006 NHL Draft
 >> 2006 NHL Awards
 ABOUT TFP
 >> About Us
 >> Our Team
 >> Contact Us

<<< Experts >>>

 

Latest Update: Dec. 1, 2005

Check in with us throughout the NHL season as The Fourth Period's brass of experts offer their opinions on major events occurring around the world of hockey. 


The Thornton Trade

On November 30, 2005, in a span of five seconds, the Boston Bruins completely altered their identity.

The Bruins traded superstar Joe Thornton to the struggling San Jose Sharks in exchange for defenseman Brad Stuart, winger Marco Sturm and forward Wayne Primeau.

The deal shook the hockey world, as many watched in disbelief as Thornton discussed his shock over the deal.

"It was definitely a shock," Thornton told TFP's James Murphy. "I was blindsided for sure. I mean, I just signed here hoping to finish my career here and I loved the guys I played with."

So what will come of this trade? Is this the beginning of a league-wide shake up? TFP's Experts offer their two-cents on the trade.

TFP Expert Comments Winner
Arpon Basu This trade is simply baffling from the Bruins perspective. The common perception is that the team who got the best player usually wins the trade, and Sharks GM Doug Wilson most definitely got the best player in this deal. 

Bruins GM Mike O'Connell should be ashamed that he didn't receive a top-line pivot man in return for Thornton, especially since his availability wasn't leaked to the media beforehand. Saying that he freed some cap space is a sorry excuse, especially since he only got about $1.6 million of wiggle room.

The media and fans in Boston have been on Thornton's case since day one for never living up to the lofty expectations placed on him as a first overall draft pick. Now they can enjoy watching Patrice Bergeron fill the role of top center. Nothing against Bergeron, but he's no Thornton. 

This seems to be the first step in a long and arduous rebuilding process for the B's, while the Sharks suddenly move back into the Western Conference elite.

Dennis Bernstein Marco Sturm is a good talent, Brad Stuart is an above average defenseman and Wayne Primeau is a solid citizen... but all that for Joe Thornton? It looks like San Jose stole him and may revive their moribund season with Patrick Marleau and Thornton 1-2 down the middle. I'd get 15 goals playing with those two feeding me. 

Boston dumps salary, but for what? If they go into the free agent market in the off-season, is there a player of equal value they could sign? At the end of the day, Boston ONLY saves $1.6 million. What quality center can you sign for that amount of money? Maybe there were signals Joe wasn't long for New England when the B's only signed him to a three year deal in the summer, instead of going for five. You can be sure that Glen Murray, who was lobbied hard by Thornton to stay in Boston, is not a very happy winger today. 

The Sharks do have a downside because they get a player who's very disappointed and sad in leaving Boston (imagine that). On his conference call last night, the bitterness was clear in Thornton's voice. 

Joe will have moral support playing with his cousin, Scott, but will his head be ready to support Team Teal when he was THE guy on the Bruins for so long? This season may be a wash for the Sharks as Thornton gets his fins wet, but once he gets settled, he'll show Boston fans it was a losing deal for them.

James P. Murphy Shocking! Sign a guy to a three-year deal and say he "is the future of our franchise," then trade him? 

Thornton was never the fiery Terry O'Reilly/ Cam Neely guy they wanted, but then why not trade him for that guy?

As for who won? The Sharks. Thornton-Primeau, 1-2 in the 1997 draft, I'd say they won!

Bruins acquire a defenseman they need, but get another Sergei Samsonov in Marco Sturm and who knows what in Wayne Primeau? Sturm makes me wonder if Samsonov is next to go, since he is set to become an unrestricted free agent this summer. Watch out for Nick Boynton to get dealt, too. Knowing how well he respected Thornton, he may want out.

David Pagnotta So, I'm buried in a pile of work and I get a phone call. "Dave, you busy," this person asks. I reply, "Just a little, what's up?" He answered back, "Well, in about five minutes your whole night is going to change."

And all of a sudden, it did.

The Bruins traded arguably their best center since the days of Adam Oates and received... well, let's just say it's far from market value.

The B's save a bit of cash, yippee! Where are they now? Stuart's a good defenseman, Sturm's on pace for a career year (57 points), and Primeau's a decent checking center. But Joe Thornton, in the old and new NHL, is a dominant superstar.

Unfortunately for Bruins fans, this could be the beginning of more changes to come. For Sharks fans, you better be glowing. Thornton was already set for a near 120-point season and you can bet he'll help all those around him. He doesn't have anything to prove, but he'd certainly love to stick it to B's management.

 

--- Who are they? ---

Arpon Basu is the Montreal Correspondent for The Fourth Period Magazine, and covers the Canadiens for TheFourthPeriod.com. He is also a beat reporter with The Canadian Press.

Dennis Bernstein, an NHL Analyst with ESPN Radio, is the Los Angeles Correspondent for The Fourth Period Magazine and covers the Kings for TheFourthPeriod.com. He is also the man behind SCORE! media.

James P. Murphy, widely known in Boston's sports media, is the Boston Correspondent for The Fourth Period Magazine, and covers the Bruins for TheFourthPeriod.com.

David Pagnotta, formerly an NHL Analyst with FOX Sports Radio, is the Editor-in-Chief of The Fourth Period Magazine and TheFourthPeriod.com, and also covers the Toronto Maple Leafs for both the website and publication.


Also read:
Oct. 09, 2005 -
2005-06 NHL predictions
Sept. 22, 2005 -
My NHL; League's new marketing campaign
Aug. 24, 2005 -
Analysis of the Hossa-for-Heatley trade

 

 Contact Us | Jobs | Advertise | Privacy Policy 
 © 2005 TFP Media, Inc. | All Rights Reserved | The Fourth Period™ is a registered trademark.