MAGAZINE > ASK DAVE > RUMORS > EXPERTS > RANKINGS > TFP RADIO SHOW > CONTACT US

 

 Home |

 >> Scores / Schedule

 >> Injuries
 NHL RUMORS
 >> Rumors
 TFP RADIO SHOW
 >> Radio Home
 >> Broadcast Schedule
 TFP MAGAZINE
 >> Magazine Home
 >> Subscribe Now!
 FEATURES
 >> Trade Deadline
 >> TFP Forums
 >> Ask Dave
 >> Rankings
 >> Experts
 >> Team Reports
 SPECIAL EVENTS
 >> 2007 World Juniors
 >> 2007 NHL Draft
 >> 2007 NHL Awards
 ABOUT TFP
 >> About Us
 >> Our Team
 >> Contact Us

 October 14, 2007
  

New York's Best Rivalry

(NEW YORK, NY) -- In baseball -- my other sport -- one of the biggest complaints about Interleague games is that the intrigue isn't there, with a few exceptions.

And really, those nay-sayers are pretty much correct. After all, how much attention does a Pirates--Twins series in June really bring? Even the people of Pittsburgh and Minnesota don't really want to see that.

Yet, every year for the last 11 seasons, series Phillies playing the Rangers and the Devil Rays having three games against the Rockies littered the schedule all because of six games:

The three games the Yankees play at Shea Stadium and the three games the Mets have in the Bronx.

Oh sure the Cubs and White Sox draw some attention and yes, it's nice to see Dodgers vs. Angels out west, but it's the Subway Series that keeps the Interleague on the schedule.

Maybe it's because MLB sees the best New York rivalry every single year unfold right its eyes, in when the Rangers play the Islanders. No matter how bad or good the Blueshirts and Isles are, every game is a war and every single inch of ice is fought for.

"It's always good to play the Islanders," said Rangers coach Tom Renney before his team lost on Wednesday at Nassau Coliseum, 2-1. "It doesn't matter when it is. I have said many times before we bring out the best and worst in each other."

Renney has a point as the Islanders seem to play their best hockey when they see the Rangers on the ice and the Blueshirts also step it up a notch.

In the pre-season, there was a goalie fight between Rick DiPietro and Al Montoya, while last year all hell almost broke lose when Chris Simon swung his stick and connected on Ryan Hollweg, then in the next game a few weeks later, a Henrik Lundqvist took some heat because he refused to get out of the way of one of the Islander Ice Girls.

And who can forget the tremendous performance by DiPietro last year, stopping a record 56 shots.

When there are the fans. Unlike Mets and Yankees, when these two hockey teams meet, it's a pretty good bet a number of fight will break out in the stands. Also, the general vigor on the various message boards borders on brutal.

Ranger fans will chant negatively about Dennis Potvin, the Hall of Fame defenseman, who retired in the late 1980s, because of a hit on Ulf Nilsson that happened back in 1979. And the Islander fans have a jingle they sing when the Blueshirts play at the Coliseum.

Let's just say, none like that happened last Sunday when the Jets played the Giants.

For Ranger fans, the Islanders are really the only rival they care about. Sure the Devils are in the same market and the Flyers aren't loved, but the hatred isn't as pronounced. Ask any Devil fan and they will tell you they hate the Rangers above all. Ask any Ranger fan and they will say the Islanders.

Plus, unlike the other New York rivalries in the other sports, the Rangers and Islanders play in the same division, meaning their games actually have an impact on the other teams’ success. Yes, the Knicks and Nets have the same, but there's really no rivalry there.

That's what makes this special. Not since the Giants were in the Polo Grounds and Dodgers played at 55 Sullivan Place, New York has not seen a more bitter rivalry.

And no matter what Major League Baseball or the NFL tries to do to have it happen in their sports, it will never be the same as Rangers vs. Islanders.
 


Joe McDonald covers the New York Rangers for TheFourthPeriod.com. He is also the publisher of NYSportsDay.com and managing editor of NY Sportscene Magazine.
 

 

 

 Contact Us | Jobs @ TFP | Advertise | Privacy Policy
 
© 2007 TFP Media, Inc. | All Rights Reserved | The Fourth Period™ is a registered trademark.